Welcome to Great American Coin Company!

1937 D Three Legged Buffalo Nickel Replica

ONE OF AMERICA'S RAREST COINS \r\n\r\nThe 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel

Availability: In stock

  • Add 5 to cart for $6.95 each and save 31%
  • Add 10 to cart for $6.00 each and save 40%
  • Add 25 to cart for $5.90 each and save 41%
  • Add 50 to cart for $5.59 each and save 44%
  • Add 100 to cart for $4.36 each and save 57%
  • Product Description
  • Reviews
  • Add Review


The 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel

This coin consists of an exact size superbly crafted collectors Proof which pays tribute to one of the rarest United States coins ever minted. As a brilliant Uncirculated reduction tribute proof. These coins are known as Bufallo, Bison, and Indian Head nickels. The first year this coin was issued was 1923, with two varieties minted.

The first showing the bison on a mound, and the second redesigned with the bison on a straight thin line. The coin was designed by James E. Fraser, with his initial 'F' visible beneath the coin's date. The bison was modeled after a buffalo named 'Black Diamond' who was housed in the New York Central Park Zoo.

No one knows how many of the genuine 1937-D three legged error coins actually exist. However, one thing is certain, these coins in proof condition sell for thousands of dollars, and are extremely rare.

If you are interested in wholesale volume, please call us toll free at 855-644-2242




Weight - 5 grams
21.2 Millimeters in Diameter
Individually Struck BU Proof Coin




The Great American Coin Company is not endorsed by or affiliated with either the United States Government or the U.S. Mint.

All Great American Coin Company replica coins, reproduction coins, or copy coins comply with the US Hobby Protection Act - 15USC-2101, regarding the sale and manufacture of reproduction coins.

Unless stated as .999 silver replica coins, all gold and silver reproduction coins are plated. All our reproduction coins, replica coins, and/or copy coins are non-monetary and cannot be used as currency.

Write Your Own Review

You're reviewing: 1937 D Three Legged Buffalo Nickel Replica

How do you rate this product? *

  1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars
Mailing List
Sign up for our email list to receive special offers and discounts